Thickened Liquid Challenge Strikes Back – #ThickenedLiquidChallenge

by: Eric Widera (@ewidera)

This week’s JAMA IMincludes a case of a woman in her 90s with advanced dementia who was started on honey-thickened liquids for aspiration prevention.   She subsequently “refused nearly all food and thickened liquids, turning her head when nurses attempted one-on-one feeding” and was transitioned to inpatient hospice care.   What happened next?  Her diet was changed to regular liquids and she was allowed to eat her favorite foods.  Two months late her weight improved with no clinically apparent aspirations.

This is the story of thickened liquids.   As the authors of the article, Drs Wang,  Charlton, and Kohlwes, explain: “thickened liquids have become a part of routine care—some might even argue the standard of care. This has created the perception that thickened liquids are beneficial and safe for patients with dementia.”  Unfortunately, the evidence base to back up its efficacy in dementia is poor and as in this case, places patients at significant risk of adverse effects.

We at GeriPal are personally proud that the authors described one of the most important interventions that providers can do when placed in situations like these where the “standard of care” is questionable at best: they tried it themselves.  The authors describe undertaking the “Thickened Liquid Challenge” by filming each other as they as they endured 12 hours of a thickened-liquid diet.   What was their conclusion after doing so?   Its summarized perfectly in their last sentence:

“The routine use of thickened liquids to prevent pneumonia in patients with dementia should be avoided, and diet should involve a comprehensive approach rather than a reflexive diet modification.”

To learn more about the #thickenedliquidchallenge, watch/read these:

• YouTube Videos of people taking the challenge
• The initial GeriPal video on the challenge 
• GeriPal post on the benefits/harms of thickened liquids
• Pallimed’s post and video on it